How to Calculate the ROI of Graduate School

How to Calculate the ROI of Graduate School

You have probably heard someone say, “Make sure you calculate the ROI before you make that big decision.” That advice is important but it’s also incomplete because most people are told to run the numbers without ever being shown how to do that. 

When it comes to the ROI of graduate school, most will agree that pursuing higher education is a major investment of your time, energy, and money. Before committing to a master’s or PhD program, you deserve a clear and grounded way to evaluate whether it aligns with your long-term goals and financial circumstances. ROI is part math and part meaning. Both matter. Here is one step-by-step way to approach it.

Step 1: Estimate Your Earning Potential

Begin with some research. Look at reliable data sources such as the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, alumni outcome reports, and professional associations in your field. Start by asking yourself: 

  • What is the typical starting salary with my current degree?
  • What is the median salary over time with my current degree?
  • What is the typical starting salary with the graduate degree I am considering?
  • What is the median salary over time with that graduate degree?

The key is the difference. ROI is about the income gap between your current trajectory and your potential trajectory with the advanced degree. For example, in 2026 an MS in Engineering may lead to a starting salary around $90,000 per year, with steady growth over time (this will vary based on region and market conditions). A PhD in Economics may lead to a job at a research university with median earnings of around $115,000. In contrast, some humanities doctorates lead to salaries that are closer to bachelor’s-level earnings in other industries.

Every field is different. Your responsibility is to gather realistic data rather than relying on anecdotes alone. 

Step 2: Calculate the Full Cost

Next, calculate what the degree will cost you in total, not just the tuition. This should include tuition and fees, health insurance and other mandatory charges, books and materials, housing and living expenses, and the income you are giving up by not working (or by working less) while enrolled. Lost wages are often the largest hidden cost, especially for multi‑year programs, and they grow further when you account for potential raises, retirement contributions, and lost employer benefits over time.

For example, if you step away from a $50,000 salary for five years, that is $250,000 in opportunity cost before any raises or retirement contributions are considered. For a two‑year MS in Computer Science, you might pay around $60,000 in tuition and fees and forgo approximately $100,000 in wages, for a total direct and opportunity cost near $160,000.

A fully funded humanities PhD may cover tuition and provide a stipend, but six or more years of earning substantially less than you could in a full‑time role can still amount to $200,000 or more in opportunity cost, even before considering slower retirement savings and delayed career progression. Even when tuition is fully funded, the income you give up and the delay in advancing your career are real financial tradeoffs.

Seeing this full picture allows you to make a more informed and realistic decision about whether a particular program is worth it for you.

Step 3: Consider Completion Rates

ROI calculations assume you finish the program but many doctoral students do not (Council of Graduate Schools 2010). Across U.S. PhD programs, about half of graduate students complete within 10 years, and completion rates vary substantially by field and institution (Council of Graduate Schools 2010).

Engineering and many other STEM fields often show completion rates around 60–65 percent (Council of Graduate Schools 2010).

Humanities programs typically report completion rates in the 40–50 percent range, with some disciplines lower (Council of Graduate Schools 2010; American Academy of Arts and Sciences 2024).

Social and behavioral science programs generally fall near or below the mid‑50 percent range, and some have median completion rates closer to one‑third within eight years (American Academy of Arts and Sciences 2024; Council of Graduate Schools 2010; Inside Higher Ed 2008; American Psychological Association 2008).

Ask every program you are seriously considering to share its recent completion, time‑to‑degree, and attrition data by field and demographic group, if they have it available. Completion is shaped by factors such as advising quality, funding stability, program climate, broader institutional culture, and your personal circumstances.

This step is not meant to discourage you; it is meant to give you a grounded picture for your own realistic planning. A strong support system, clear expectations about milestones and timelines, and proactive communication with your advisor and other professors on your committee all increase your likelihood of finishing.

Step 4: Look Beyond Salary

Financial ROI is only one dimension of what you gain from the program. But graduate education can also offer intellectual fulfillment, professional autonomy, expanded leadership opportunities, and community impact. Consider asking yourself:

  • Will this degree bring me closer to the kind of work I want to do, given how graduates from this program actually fare in the job market?
  • Will the funding and completion rates in this field support my long‑term wellbeing (financially, physically, and emotionally)?
  • Does this path align with my values, including the kinds of problems I want to work on and the communities I want to serve?

Some degrees have modest financial returns and very strong personal and community returns, especially in humanities and social impact‑oriented fields. Others have strong earning potential but come with higher attrition risk, longer hours, or significant stress, which also costs you. You are allowed to weigh all of these tradeoffs—financial, personal, and relational—and to decide that the “right” ROI for you is the one that best fits your goals, values, and risk-tolerance too.

Step 5: Understand the Math in Plain Language

The central financial question for calculating the math is relatively simple. How long will it take for the higher salary to cover what I spent to get the degree? If math feels overwhelming, break it down into three steps:

1) Subtract your current salary from your projected salary.

2) Write down your total program cost.

3) Divide total cost by the yearly salary difference.

The formula looks like this: Total Cost ÷ Annual Salary Increase = Years to Break Even

Again, you are asking, “How many years of earning more will it take to recover what I spent?” Even rough estimates can provide more clarity. 

It is also important to name what this simple formula does not include. These calculations do not account for student loan interest, other loan fees, repayment timelines, taxes, inflation, or retirement contributions you may have missed during your program. Interest alone can significantly increase the true cost of borrowing.

Nevertheless, this step gives you a baseline estimate. If you anticipate taking out loans, consider running a second calculation that includes projected interest or speaking with a financial professional to understand your full repayment picture.

Four Sample Scenarios

If you’re still with me and you want to see how this plays out with scenarios, here are a few: 

Maria earns an MS in Data Science. Without the degree, she would earn $60,000 per year. With it, she starts at $100,000 per year, creating a $40,000 annual increase. Her total program cost is $80,000. At that rate, she recoups her investment in at least two years of higher earnings. For her, the financial return is clear and relatively quick.

Luis pursues a fully funded PhD in History. Without the degree, he could earn $55,000 per year working full time. During his six-year program, he earns a $30,000 annual stipend, creating a $25,000 yearly gap and about $150,000 in lost wages. After graduation, he earns $65,000 per year, which is $10,000 more than his alternative path. At that rate, it could take 15 years or more to recover the opportunity cost. For Luis, the financial return is slower and closely tied to his commitment to teaching and research.

Priya considers a PhD in Sociology that is not funded. Without the degree, she would earn $60,000 per year. The program would cost over $100,000 in tuition and living expenses, and she would also forgo income during her studies. If her projected post-PhD salary increases to $75,000 per year, that is a $15,000 annual increase. At that rate, it could take more than six years to recover tuition alone, without accounting for lost wages. After reviewing her numbers and goals, she decides the opportunity cost feels too high and explores alternative pathways.

Jaden completes a one-year Master’s in Public Policy. Without the degree, they earn $50,000 per year. With it, they earn $70,000 per year, creating a $20,000 annual increase. The program costs $45,000. At that rate, the degree pays for itself in just over two years of higher earnings. For Jaden, the return is focused, time-bound, and aligned with their career goals.

Each decision in these hypothetical scenarios are grounded in both data and each individual’s personal values.

A Simple Framework for Your Decision

When you bring this together, ask yourself:

  • What is the realistic income difference with this degree?
  • What is the full financial and opportunity cost?
  • How likely am I to complete the program?
  • How does this align with my long-term goals?

You deserve to have access to information that provides clarity before making a multi-year financial and life commitment. Running the numbers does not completely remove uncertainty but it does give you steadier footing.

I know from experience that graduate school can open many doors. It can also reshape your finances in ways that can potentially help or harm you. When you evaluate both the financial return and the personal return, you are making a decision from a place of internal awareness rather than external pressure.

ROI depends on your field, your funding, your support system, and your goals. Take the time to calculate it carefully. Then choose the path that feels most reasonable and aligned for you.

References:

American Academy of Arts and Sciences. Attrition in Humanities Doctorate Programs. Cambridge, MA: American Academy of Arts and Sciences, 2024.

American Psychological Association. “PhD Completion Varies by Sex, Race.” gradPSYCH Magazine, 2008.

Council of Graduate Schools. Ph.D. Completion and Attrition: Analysis of Baseline Program Data. Washington, DC: Council of Graduate Schools, 2010.

Inside Higher Ed. “Ph.D. Completion Gaps.” Inside Higher Ed, September 8, 2008.

Educational Disclaimer: This content is provided for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute financial, legal, tax, or investment advice, and it should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional guidance. You are solely responsible for your decisions, actions, and outcomes. For advice tailored to your specific financial circumstances, consult a licensed financial, tax, or legal professional.

 


 

This post was written by Dra. Yvette Martínez-Vu, a first-generation, disabled, and autistic Chicana grad school and productivity coach, consultant, and LinkedIn Learning instructor.

She is the co-author of Is Grad School For Me? (UC Press) and co-editor of the Chicana M(other)work Anthology (UA Press). As the founder of Grad School Femtoring, LLC and host of the award-winning Grad School Femtoring Podcast, she helps first-gen BIPOC students and professionals navigate academia and careers with sustainable productivity strategies.

Her work focuses on grad admissions, executive functioning, flexible work systems, burnout prevention, and values-aligned success. Dra. Yvette offers coaching, consulting, and speaking engagements on grad school admissions, career development, productivity, and wellbeing. Learn more at: https://gradschoolfemtoring.com/about/

Did you ♥ this post? Let me know.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Grad School Femtoring
Email List