394: Toxic Advisor Horror Stories That Keep Grad Students Up at Night

394: Toxic Advisor Horror Stories That Keep Grad Students Up at Night

In this episode of the Grad School Femtoring podcast, I share five toxic advisor horror stories inspired by recurring themes from coaching conversations and online graduate student discussions. These anonymous composite stories explore humiliating feedback, hurtful comments after qualifying exams, advisors who disappear, constantly changing expectations, and delayed dissertation signatures. Along the way, I reflect on my own experience receiving a painful comment about my writing and affirm that graduate students deserve respectful communication and meaningful support.

I also discuss what you can reasonably expect from an advisor, including constructive feedback, clear turnaround times, guidance through academic milestones, and appropriate boundaries. I share ways to clarify expectations, seek additional mentorship, explore changing advisors, and process difficult experiences while rebuilding your sense of agency.

In this episode, you will learn:

  • How to recognize constructive academic feedback and identify humiliating comments.
  • What communication, feedback, and guidance you can reasonably expect from an advisor.
  • How to clarify revision priorities and feedback timelines when expectations keep changing.
  • What to consider before changing advisors, including funding, research, and graduation timelines.
  • How to seek support and regain a sense of agency after a hurtful advising experience.

Work with me

  • If you’re navigating a difficult advising relationship or preparing for a major academic milestone, I offer personalized support to help you clarify your options and create a plan aligned with your capacity and goals. Learn more about my coaching services here: https://gradschoolfemtoring.com/coaching/

Free resource

Explore more

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

394: Toxic Advisor Horror Stories That Keep Grad Students Up at Night

===

[00:00:00]

Dra Yvette Martinez-Vu: Imagine spending weeks working on a paper only to have your advisor tell you that your writing is worse than an undergrad's. Or imagine getting through your dissertation qualifying exams, a milestone that you've been working toward for months, if not years, only to hear your committee say, " That was awful, but we're gonna pass you anyway."

Or imagine finishing your dissertation, completing all the requirements, and then filing it only to wait months, if not a year, for your advisor to sign off on it.

Unfortunately, these kinds of experiences happen, and over the years, through my work as a grad school coach and someone who has also navigated grad school myself, I've heard countless stories about difficult and even toxic advising relationships. I've also seen countless grad students sharing similar experiences online, [00:01:00] including in Reddit threads, where students turn to strangers to share their experiences and ask for advice or validation.

And so for today's episode, I'm gonna be sharing anonymous stories inspired by recurring themes from my own coaching conversations and also from some of the notes that I've noticed in those Reddit threads. And keep in mind, I've changed some of the details to protect confidentiality, so no one story represents a single individual.

But I'm sharing them because I've had enough with commonalities over the years that you might find yourself represented in some of these, but I'm not referring to one specific person when I talk about this. So let me tell you what the goal is for today. I want to remind you that if you relate to any of the experiences that I share today, please know you're not alone, and you do not deserve this.

[00:02:00] Second, I want you to understand what you should reasonably expect from an advisor. And third, I wanna share strategies for navigating difficult advising relationships, including what to do. Sometimes it might mean changing advisors. Sometimes it means changing your strategy while still working with the same person.

So with that being said, let's get into these grad school horror stories.

Welcome to the award-winning Grad School Femtoring Podcast, the place where first-generation BIPOC students and professionals can listen in on inclusive grad school stories and gain practical tools for sustainable success. This is Doctora Yvette Martinez-Vu, a certified coach, consultant, author, and speaker.

I will be [00:03:00] serving as your femtor, providing you with insider knowledge to help you thrive in grad school and beyond.

Welcome back everyone to another episode of the Grad School Femtoring Podcast. This is your host, Doctora Yvette. Today, I'm talking about something that sounds like a Halloween episode and of course, this is timely in that I am publishing it in the month of October.

Except that these stories, sadly, are not fictional. They are all too familiar, and they do happen to grad students. I'm sharing this this month because I'm gonna be sharing a couple of spooky episodes. So today's episode is all on advisor horror stories, and then the next episode is gonna be on grad school horror stories and why some people regret their degrees.

But again, today it's about the advisor [00:04:00] horror stories of the kinds of experiences that keep grad students up at night, the experiences that might make you question your abilities, and sometimes they make you wonder whether or not you want to even stay in your program. So our first story involves a grad student who has been working really hard on a paper for weeks, maybe months.

They've read the literature. They have an argument. They've revised their writing. They finally send it out for review from their advisor, and when they meet with their advisor, the advisor looks at it and says something along the lines of, "This is worse than something I would expect from an undergraduate."

Oof, that line stings. And I will say this, I will actually disclose, I had something like this happen very similarly to me, and I will never forget that comment. [00:05:00] And so that comment is not very helpful. There's no meaningful explanation about what needs improvement. There's no discussion about how to strengthen the argument.

It's just a comment that makes you feel humiliated. And here is what makes this kind of experience so difficult. Instead of leaving the meeting thinking, "Oh, I just need to improve my paper in this way or in that way," you leave thinking, "Maybe I'm not smart enough to be here.

Maybe everyone else knows what they're doing, and I don't. Maybe they admitted me by mistake." And if you're feeling this way, I want to make something clear. Graduate level writing requires time, energy, practice, and a lot of iteration. Your first draft might still need substantial revisions. That's completely understandable.

And yes, your advisor might find some serious problems with your writing, with your argument, your methods, how you engage with the literature. [00:06:00] All of that is part of the process. But there is a difference between receiving rigorous academic feedback and being flat-out humiliated. Constructive feedback gives you useful information.

So if an advisor tells you, "Okay, I need your argument to be clearer. I need you to engage more with the scholarship. The evidence that you provided doesn't fully support your claims." I get that. Those might still be hard to get, but at least you have something to work with. Versus someone telling you that your writing is awful or that it's worse than an undergrad.

That doesn't really give you a sense of direction. And I want you to know that whenever you receive a critique of your work, please don't personalize it. It's not an indication of your potential, your intelligence, your worth, and so forth, even if it feels that way in that moment [00:07:00] with that initial sting.

So if you've experienced something similar, again, please try to differentiate the comment from the actual useful task. What is actionable about the feedback? And if nothing is actionable, then that was just flat-out humiliation, and you don't deserve that. The next story is the story of a doctoral student who finally reached the dissertation qualifying exam stage, and they have worked on their coursework, they've completed research, they've written some papers, they've worked on revisions.

They've spent so many hours reviewing academic literature. And so of course, you're getting to that point of taking the exam, you're feeling nervous, but you've done the best to prepare, at least the best based on your circumstances. And so you write your papers, maybe you're [00:08:00] required to work on a presentation, maybe you have to deliver that presentation in front of a committee, you answer their questions, and then that moment comes.

Those of y'all that are in doctoral programs, you know this moment all too well. Most of us have had this type of moment where they send you outside while your committee is inside a room, and they deliberate. And so you're there, you're waiting, and they bring you back in, and then your worst-case scenario happens.

Well, maybe not the worst case, second to worst-case scenario. They say that your performance was awful, but that they're going to pass you anyway. I say this is the second to worst-case scenario because I've also heard stories where they've told people that they didn't do well enough to pass, and they didn't pass them.

Imagine hearing that. Imagine hearing, "It was terrible, it was awful, it was horrible," but they're gonna pass you anyway. So you've just prepared [00:09:00] one of your biggest academic milestones, and instead of being able to celebrate, you're left wondering, "Why did they even pass me? Did I deserve the pass?"

And maybe you're, like, replaying that moment over and over and over in your head, and you think about everything that you wrote. You think about the presentation. You think about every question that you had a hard time answering, and every moment that you hesitated, and every single time that you wish you had done something differently.

But this is an exam, so remember, you're not supposed to know everything. If you knew everything, then you might not need to be in a graduate program to begin with. So committee members are going to ask you challenging questions. They are going to find your weaknesses. They are going to find the gaps, and they often ask for revisions. And sadly though, sometimes [00:10:00] you have an exam that doesn't go as smoothly as you hoped, and it comes with some mean things that they say.

It's one thing for your committee to say that you just barely passed or that you didn't meet the requirements to pass, and it's another thing for them to say, "It was awful, it was terrible, it was horrible." And nonetheless, this is something that I tell a lot of my clients, you will remember this because I sound like a broken record.

I say this to my kids as well. A pass is a pass is a pass is a pass. If you pass, no matter what they said about your performance, about what you did, about the quality of your work, you still passed, and you're allowed to acknowledge and celebrate the accomplishment. And I also wanna remind you that just because you had a less than ideal exam and just because they did not say the nicest things about you or your work, you [00:11:00] still have something worth celebrating.

And so I encourage you to do what you need to do to process what happened, talk to someone you trust, if you need to, process it with a mental health professional, with a therapist, and then take a look at the actionable feedback and keep moving forward because again, just like I said with the first story, you don't deserve to be humiliated even if you need to do more work. All right, let's talk about this third story.

Oh my gosh, this one frustrates me so much. This is the story of an advisor that ghosts you. This is the advisor that's hard to reach. Maybe you're trying to reach out and send your writing, you're submitting chapters, and then you send something in September, and you hear nothing. You follow up in October, you hear nothing.

You follow up in November, and at this point you're wondering if this person is [00:12:00] alive. So you finally get a meeting scheduled on the calendar, and then your advisor says they haven't had time to read it. Oof. So you wait and wait and wait, and months go by, and your graduation timeline is getting pushed back because of this person.

And then you start to realize that your funding might be running out. Maybe you have a postdoc or a job lined up and that deadline's coming up. Maybe you might need to pay additional tuition and fees so you can stay another quarter or semester to wait for that feedback. And it's incredibly frustrating because it's outside of your control in that you've been doing what you need to do.

You've been doing your work. You've been writing. You've been submitting drafts. You've been following up. You're trying to do everything that you can to make decent progress, but then you can't because you're waiting on someone else. And I've heard so many variations of this story. [00:13:00] Sometimes people say that they've never received any written feedback from their advisors. And just as a heads up, if someone else who has worked with your advisor before tells you something like that, like, "Hey, I never got any feedback from this person," please take that as a red flag and take it seriously.

And I get that sometimes advisors are hands-off. Sometimes they have different mentoring styles. Some folks are more hands-on. They might meet with you regularly. They might give constant feedback. Nevertheless, you still deserve to have access to appropriate feedback and mentorship. If you're sending work over and over again with no feedback, you deserve to ask for that and to get clearer expectations from this person.

You wanna find out how long do you need to submit feedback, and what's the best way for you to give me my feedback? I wanna establish a timeline [00:14:00] for this feedback so that I can keep meeting my milestones. What's your turnover time or turnaround time for this chapter or for each chapter moving forward?

And then if need be, sometimes you might need to lean on another committee member, or sometimes you might need to get a co-chair, or you have to figure something out so that you can get feedback from someone. So please, please know that you deserve to get some feedback, and you deserve guidance from your advisor.

If you're feeling stuck in grad school or navigating a major professional transition, personalized coaching from a certified coach can make a meaningful difference. I offer one-on-one coaching for first gen and/or BIPOC graduate students and professionals who want structure and compassionate support while working toward important goals.

Together, we can create action plans that align with your capacity, your responsibilities, and your [00:15:00] long-term vision. Clients often come to coaching when they are preparing for major milestones like qualifying exams, defending a proposal, finishing dissertations, exploring new career paths, or building sustainable systems that work for them.

Coaching includes live sessions, voice memo, and email support between sessions, and access to a resource library filled with dozens of tools for academic and professional success. If you'd like to explore working together, visit gradschoolfemtoring.com/coaching to learn more and schedule a free consultation today.

I'm moving on to story four, and this is the advisor who keeps moving the goalpost.

Oof, this one. They're all frustrating. I don't even know why I keep saying this one's especially frustrating. But let's say you've been working on a dissertation proposal. You meet with your advisor, you [00:16:00] discuss your research questions, you agree on a plan, and you spend months working and developing that plan.

And then when you submit your work, your advisor suddenly tells you that you need to take the project in a completely different direction. This is not working. So you revise it. You change your research questions, you update the lit review, you rethink your methods, and you submit another draft. And once again, your advisor changes the expectations.

At some point, you start wondering, "Hold up, like, am I doing everything wrong? What exactly am I supposed to be doing here?" And this is what happens when you have an advisor that is unclear and keeps having you move the goalpost. And this is especially frustrating when you're trying to finish your degree within a particular timeline.

And it's understandable for your research to evolve and for your topic to grow and develop over time, but it's a completely different [00:17:00] thing when your advisor's having you change your topic over and over and over again. So I want you to know that, that it's completely normal for you to update your work based on new evidence, or maybe your methodology doesn't work, so you have to change it.

Like, those things come up But what's not okay is if you keep getting repeated changes over and over and over again, and your advisor's the type of person that refuses to green-light your work. They refuse to get you to a stage where you can move on to writing another chapter or to the next milestone in your program.

So if this is happening to you, I highly recommend that you clarify expectations with your advisor, that you find out what's the criteria that they're gonna use to determine whether a chapter is ready to go. And ask them about, you know, what major revisions they [00:18:00] would like you to prioritize, especially given your timeline.

Ask them how their changes are gonna affect your timeline, because sometimes advisors, they won't even think about your timeline at all. They'll just keep having you change things, revise things, revise things, and then next thing you know, you find yourself spending an entire year on one chapter. And then if you have to write four or five chapters, do you really wanna be spending a year per chapter?

I don't think so. So that's why it's useful to bring up the conversation of your timeline, so that way you can reduce confusion and have a greater sense of at what point you can move on. Because again, you deserve to make progress at a pace that works for you, not just the pace that works with your advisor. The fifth story, is similar to this one.

It's the advisor that doesn't let you finish. And so let's say you have done the work. You did the research, you wrote the [00:19:00] chapters, you addressed feedback, and you submitted your final materials. So you're ready. You're ready to finish. You're ready to move on. Except there's one problem. Your advisor hasn't signed off on it.

Weeks pass, maybe months pass, maybe even a year has gone by. And I heard a story about this similarly, and my jaw dropped because I could not believe it, that someone mentioned to me that they knew of someone else who filed their dissertation and it took a year for either the advisor or the committee members or all of them, I can't remember the details, for them to sign off on it, for them to finish.

So imagine you're following up, you're trying to figure out what's happening, your plans are on hold. Maybe you're waiting to start a job. Maybe you've got a postdoc lined up. Maybe you're just ready to move on with your life and you can't. You're in limbo. You feel powerless because one person, or sometimes it's three or four, depending on your [00:20:00] committee, they have so much control over your future.

You're waiting on these signatures. And that, I don't even know what to say about this because at this point you've done everything you need to do. You're just waiting on someone. And I don't understand the circumstances behind why some individuals might wait so long to sign off on something. But I will say that if you've gotten to a point where you've invested so much time, labor, energy, resources into completing your degree, the least that they can do is sign off on it.

So if that's not happening, you need to escalate things, you need to talk to some other people, and you need to get the ball rolling in some way, shape, or form instead of letting things slide.

All right, those were the stories I wanted to share, and now I'm feeling angry. Oh, I'm angry and frustrated for you.

But I wanna remind you that there are things that you can reasonably expect from an advisor. Because at this point you might be thinking to yourself, [00:21:00] "Okay, what should a good advisor actually be doing? Like, what should I look for in a good advisor?" Well, first, you should have respectful and professional communication.

You may or may not know, I actually don't even like the word professional because of what it implicates around, professionalism and white supremacy culture, and feeling like you can't show up as your full self in certain spaces. But in this case, I'm talking about being respectful. And so yes, your advisor can challenge your ideas, question your assumptions, and push you to become a stronger scholar. But they should be able to do that without belittling you and without humiliating you.

Second, you should expect constructive feedback. That is the basics. That is something that everyone should expect. You should get feedback from your advisor. [00:22:00] That doesn't always mean line by line edits, but it does mean some guidance to help you get a sense of what's working, what needs improvement, and how to make progress on your work.

Third, you should expect clarity around how you communicate with them and around your timeline. Yes, your advisor is probably very busy. Who isn't? And yes, I know that every advisor's turnaround time is different. Some folks are pretty quick, some folks need a week, couple weeks, sometimes even a month. But you should at least know what their turnaround time is.

You need to know when you can reasonably expect feedback from them and how often you can meet with them. Fourth, you should expect guidance around academic milestones. I get your advisor might not be a friend, your advisor might not be someone you can be vulnerable with, but they should at least guide you in reaching your program [00:23:00] milestones.

They need to help you understand requirements. They need to help you understand the expectations that are relevant to your research and degree progress. And fifth, you should expect appropriate professional boundaries.

You're a grad student. You're still developing as a scholar, and nevertheless, you deserve to be treated with dignity. I want you to remember that. Yes, I want you to do work that matters. Yes, I want you to strengthen your writing, your research skills, and so forth. And yes, I also recognize that no advisor's gonna meet every single need that you have.

Nevertheless, they should not treat you badly. Nevertheless, they should respect you. Nevertheless, they should be kind to you. This is another reason for why I encourage folks to tap into finding mentors outside of just their advisor and their committee members, because you'll find that [00:24:00] once you start working with different people, once you start leaning on a wider support system, you'll recognize that, one, you'll get more of your needs met, and two, you'll start to realize what you deserve and what you don't deserve.

In some cases, toxic advisors are so terrible that you might need to change advisors. And I know that this is not an option for everyone, but I want you to recognize it as an option if that's a possibility for you, if it's something that you've seen other people do in your program, or if there are multiple people in your department that are doing work that could align with yours.

And so ask yourself, "Can I switch advisors?" And in a lot of programs, that will be true, and there's usually a formal process for changing advisors. There's usually even a form that you sign off on, so that way you make it clear. And the options of switching advisors really [00:25:00] depends on your department, what stage you're at in your program, any funding arrangements, and so forth.

But it is something worth considering. Sometimes an advising relationship isn't just about a poor fit. Sometimes it's not just about, like, research interests. Sometimes it's about other things. Sometimes you are forced to change advisors because your advisor leaves the ins titution. Or sometimes you're just dealing with behavior that's completely unacceptable, unsustainable, and even harmful to you.

So if you're considering a change, I want you to start gathering some info. Review your graduate student handbook. Talk to people that you trust. So speak confidentially with trusted individuals. Sometimes that might mean also consulting with the ombuds office. And find out if there's other people who might be available to [00:26:00] advise you.

And keep in mind that you should find out how this could change and impact your funding, your research, and even your timeline. And then also find out, like, what it would be like to work with this new person that you're considering. What do they communicate like? What kind of support can they provide?

Could this person become a co-chair? Every situation, every department is different, but please, please keep in mind what all of your options are, because I don't want you to settle for less if you don't have to.

All right. So before I wrap up, I wanna talk a little bit more about how you move on from having experienced something terrible.

Let's say someone said something hurtful, let's say someone dismissed you, let's say someone's making you feel completely neglected or unsupported. What do you do? 'Cause I know from experience that this stays with you. [00:27:00] Sometimes it stays with you for days, weeks, months, years, and sometimes it's something that you will never forget.

If that's true, I want you to think about, well, one, what actually happened and what meaning have I attached to it? And then, let's say you're thinking about your advisor criticizing your writing, and maybe you made that mean that you are a terrible writer or that you don't belong in academia.

And then I want you to actually examine that conclusion and figure out, do I actually have evidence that this is true? Because most of the time they were just being mean, and it's not necessarily an indication of your work. So I want you to consider that. Consider what information is actually factual and what information is just based on the emotions that I'm feeling right now, and then think about what can I take from this experience.

So in my case, when I [00:28:00] got that really mean comment about my writing, I took that as a way for me to acknowledge all the ways I don't want to be as a mentor and femtor to others, that I don't ever want to say something like that to anyone and to make someone feel that way. The other thing I want you to consider is what can you do to help you regain a sense of agency?

Because if someone has said something that harmed you, sometimes it can make you feel little or it can make you feel less than. And so what can you do out of this? Can you talk to someone else that you trust who can remind you of your worth? Can you make a plan for your next academic milestone to remind you that you wanna stick to that plan and that timeline?

Can you change advisors so that you can work with someone who's gonna be more kind and supportive to you? Or maybe you just give yourself permission to acknowledge that this was a hard [00:29:00] moment and that you're gonna give yourself time to fully recover and process from it. Nevertheless, there's something that you can do as a result of this.

So to close today, I wanna acknowledge that grad school is hard. That's true for most of us. And I wanna acknowledge that you should expect to receive feedback, and sometimes that feedback is challenging. I also want you to acknowledge that it's understandable to encounter obstacles, a feeling of uncertainty, and moments when things don't go according to plan.

And nevertheless, you do not deserve to be treated like trash. You do not deserve to be belittled. You do not deserve to be humiliated. You deserve to have support. You deserve to have access to people and resources that guide you and that are gonna help you get to the next step. And so if that's not true, please, please, please do something to go seek that [00:30:00] out because you deserve better.

That's it for this episode. I hope that you found it helpful and as always, I will talk to you all next time.

Thanks so much for listening. If you liked what you heard, here are three ways you can support the show. The first is to make sure you're subscribed and leave a review on Apple Podcasts. The second way is to get your copy of my free resource kit linked in my show notes. This kit includes tools, worksheets, and curated podcast playlists to guide you through applying to and navigating grad school.

The third way to support my show is by joining my email newsletter, where I share key takeaways and additional resources. Thanks again for listening, and until next time

Did you ♥ this episode? Let me know.

Grad School Femtoring
Email List